In The Summer I Turned Pretty, the love triangle between Belly Conklin and the Fisher brothers — Conrad and Jeremiah — has captured hearts and sparked  Team Conrad or Team Jeremiah debate. Both brothers love Belly deeply, but in very different ways. As the series unfolds, fans continue to ask: who truly deserves her heart?

Whether you’re Team Conrad or Team Jeremiah, there’s no denying that this emotional tug-of-war is what gives the story its lasting power — a mix of first love, heartbreak, and self-discovery.

Conrad Fisher: The Brooding First Love

Conrad is the definition of the classic first love — quiet, complicated, and magnetic. He’s introspective and often struggles to express his feelings, which makes his connection with Belly both passionate and painful.
His love isn’t loud; it’s deep, consuming, and marked by hesitation. Beneath his distant exterior lies a heart full of loyalty and fear — fear of losing control, of being vulnerable, and of not being enough.

For many fans, that’s exactly what makes Conrad irresistible. He represents the bittersweet ache of growing up and learning that love isn’t always easy — but it’s real.

Jeremiah Fisher: The Sunshine Soul

Where Conrad is reserved, Jeremiah is open-hearted and warm. He makes Belly laugh, supports her dreams, and never hides his feelings. His love is easy, kind, and refreshingly uncomplicated.
Jeremiah’s emotional honesty is what makes him such a strong contender for Belly’s heart. He offers her stability — the kind of love that feels safe rather than stormy.

But that doesn’t mean Jeremiah’s love is shallow. His willingness to love without restraint, even when it hurts, shows a maturity that contrasts beautifully with Conrad’s inner turmoil.

Belly Conklin: The Heart That Must Choose

At the center of it all is Belly — a girl learning that love can be both exhilarating and confusing. Her relationships with the Fisher brothers mirror her own journey of self-discovery.
Conrad awakens her sense of longing and complexity, while Jeremiah gives her comfort and confidence. Belly’s struggle isn’t just about choosing between two people; it’s about understanding what kind of love she truly wants — the kind that challenges her or the one that grounds her.

Love, Growth, and Timing

Ultimately, The Summer I Turned Pretty isn’t just a love triangle — it’s a story about timing. Sometimes, the right person comes at the wrong time, and sometimes love matures only after loss and change.
Conrad and Jeremiah both love Belly deeply, but in their own ways. Who “deserves” her heart might depend on when she’s ready to love herself fully.

That’s what makes this story resonate so strongly — it’s not just about who wins her heart, but about how all three characters grow through love, pain, and forgiveness.

FAQ

1. Why do fans prefer Conrad over Jeremiah?
Many fans are drawn to Conrad’s quiet intensity and emotional depth. His read more here yeema movies love for Belly feels raw and complicated, which mirrors the messiness of real-life first love.

2. Why do others support Jeremiah?
Jeremiah’s openness and positivity make him more emotionally available. Fans appreciate that he treats Belly with warmth, honesty, and unconditional care.

3. Who does Belly end up with in The Summer I Turned Pretty?
(For those avoiding spoilers) — the story explores both relationships across the books and series. Ultimately, Belly’s choice reflects her emotional growth and understanding of what love truly means.